Only those within the Sistine Chapel truly know the deliberations that led to Leo XIV’s election as the successor to Pope Francis on the second day of the conclave. But the timing feels far from accidental. That the first American pope should emerge just as the United States, under a newly re-elected President Donald Trump, is retreating from long-held global alliances and reshaping its domestic and foreign identity raises a compelling question: were the cardinals, consciously or not, offering a different vision of what American leadership can mean—one rooted in humility, moral clarity, and spiritual authority?
The new pope’s personal journey may help explain his election.
Cardinal Robert Prevost, now Pope Leo XIV, spent decades outside the United States as a missionary, including 20 years in Peru, where he became a naturalized citizen and served as a bishop. Fluent in multiple languages, he made no mention of his American roots during his first public appearance as pontiff. Instead, he spoke in Italian and Spanish, offering a heartfelt greeting to his “dear diocese of Chiclayo” in Peru. It was a subtle yet powerful message: though born in the United States, he is not bound by it—politically, culturally, or symbolically.
In an era marked by rising nationalism, the return of authoritarian politics, and widening global inequality, the cardinals appear to have chosen a leader shaped by life among the poor and marginalized—especially in Latin America, where many migrants to the U.S. begin their journeys. As the United States tightens borders and slashes foreign aid—such as cuts to health programs through USAID in Africa—Leo XIV brings with him a record of lived solidarity with the vulnerable.
To call his election a direct rebuke of Trumpism would oversimplify a decision rooted in centuries of ecclesiastical tradition. But it’s hard to ignore the contrast. At a moment when U.S. policy leans toward retrenchment and hard power, the Roman Catholic Church has elevated a pope who embodies compassion, humility, and a distinctly global sense of mission—reminding the world that the Vatican has long practiced power with an eye toward moral symbolism and geopolitical nuance.
Two Americans on the World Stage
Whatever the motivations behind the cardinals’ decision, Thursday’s events in the Vatican have created a striking new reality: two Americans now occupy positions of immense global influence—one in politics, the other in spiritual leadership. As President Donald Trump commands international attention from the White House, Pope Leo XIV is poised to do the same from the Vatican. The inevitable comparisons—and likely contrasts—between the two will be hard to miss. If the papacy of the late Pope Francis is any indication, those differences may only deepen over time.
This development arrives at a moment of intense reflection on America’s identity, both at home and abroad. It may provoke deeper questions about the nation’s values and its evolving role on the world stage.
“I am an American, I love America, I love the values that we stand for,” said Rev. Robert Hagan, a friend of the new pope. Speaking to CNN’s Jake Tapper, Hagan described Leo XIV as “a man of depth, strength, and serenity,” and acknowledged America’s flaws. “Sometimes the perception of us is rightly deserved… But I think in Leo XIV, we have really what the best of America stands for—peace, justice, and opportunity for all.”
While many Americans may search for symbolic meaning in the election of one of their own, it’s possible that nationality played only a limited role. Pope Leo rose through the Church hierarchy under Pope Francis, eventually taking on a key leadership post within the Vatican. His election signals continuity with Francis’ papacy—particularly its focus on the poor and a willingness to embrace reform-minded theology.
Even some of his fellow Americans were taken by surprise. Bishop Robert Barron of Rochester, Minnesota, told CNN’s Erin Burnett he was “shocked” by the outcome. “I told interviewers the day before the conclave, ‘They’ll never elect an American pope.’ America dominates the world politically, economically, and culturally—I thought the Church would never hand it spiritual authority as well. I was wrong.”
When asked if the choice reflected a broader statement about America, Barron responded: “I really think they chose the man. He’s uniquely qualified—yes, he’s American, but he served in Latin America, speaks fluent Italian, understands the Vatican inside and out. When you look at the full picture, you see someone truly prepared for this role.”
Political Reactions to Pope Leo Already Stirring Debate in the U.S.
Predictably, in a deeply polarized America, the election of Pope Leo XIV is already igniting political debate. Voices from the Make America Great Again movement expressed skepticism and disappointment on social media Thursday, with some conservatives lamenting the cardinals’ choice. They had hoped for a pontiff who would mark a decisive break from the legacy of Pope Francis, particularly on issues like climate change and immigration.
Francis had been an outspoken critic of former President Trump’s immigration policies, denouncing mass deportations as assaults on human dignity. He even appeared to indirectly confront Vice President JD Vance—a Catholic convert—for defending those policies using theological arguments. Given Pope Leo’s close alignment with Francis during his rise through the Church, some observers expect he may share similar views, though perhaps expressed in a more measured tone, at least early in his papacy.
Fueling further speculation, an X (formerly Twitter) account bearing Prevost’s name has come under scrutiny for reposting articles critical of Vance and Trump’s immigration agenda. Although the posts weren’t authored by Prevost himself, their presence has drawn attention. CNN has contacted the Vatican, X, and close associates of the pope, but has not yet confirmed whether the account is officially connected to Leo XIV.
Despite ideological tensions, Trump responded with unexpected diplomacy, telling reporters at the White House, “To have the Pope from America is a great honor.”
Still, while some liberals view Leo’s elevation as a symbolic departure from the conservatism they associate with Trump-era politics, the reality is more complex. The Roman Catholic Church often defies the binary boundaries of American political ideology. Francis, for example, pushed the Church toward greater inclusivity for LGBTQ Catholics but maintained doctrinal opposition to abortion and the ordination of women—stances that continue to divide Catholics across the ideological spectrum.
These internal schisms now intersect with an unstable global context—wars in Ukraine and Gaza, rising authoritarianism, and deepening divisions in the Global South. It is against this fraught backdrop that Pope Leo XIV begins his pontificate, inheriting a Church in search of unity amid a fractured world.
His first words, spoken from the Vatican balcony to a watching world, signaled a hope for healing: “Peace be with you.” With that, the first American pope stepped into history not as a political actor, but as a spiritual bridge.
+ There are no comments
Add yours